Why winning the argument on cycling isn’t the same as winning someone over

A group of people sat in rows in a large room. They are facing a table with three people sat at it, beneath a screen showing a slide which says 'Reframing the message: local campaigning conference'
Do we spend too much time trying to convince people that we’re right, and not enough time listening to them? That was the crucial question from ‘Reframing the message’, Cycling UK’s local campaigning conference. Campaigns Manager Sophie Gordon sums up some lessons learned from the day

On 14 November, cycling advocates gathered for Cycling UK’s first local campaigning conference for many years, held in partnership with Reading Cycle Campaign.

Our mission: to figure out why we’re not always successful with convincing people that cycling is a good thing. We know there are so many benefits: why isn’t it obvious to everyone else?

We heard perspectives from Chris Boardman, National Active Travel Commissioner for England, and Lee Waters, Former Welsh Government Deputy Minister for Climate Change. Campaign groups shared their successes for winning hearts and minds, and lessons learned along the way.

Through fascinating discussions and workshops, we began to spot the common mistakes we’ve all been making, and how we can avoid them.

Here are the five most useful things I learned from the day.

1. Don’t ‘sell’ people cycling – offer them a choice

The day kicked off with some great food for thought from Chris Boardman – his keynote speech is well worth watching.

Most people don’t care about cycling. They care about their family, their health, getting to work on time, being able to pay their bills. We need to ask people what matters to them, really listen to the answer, then help them explore what might make it possible for them.

How would it feel if they didn’t have to drive their kids to school every day? What could make that happen? Or what would a thriving town centre look like, where people want to linger? What’s stopping that happening now? What decisions can they make which might affect that?

The most important thing: offer them a choice. If they are happy to live with the problem, they can. If they want to do something about it, they can. Make it their decision.

2. Should we combat emotion with emotion as well as evidence?

As the minister who brought in the default 20mph policy for residential streets in Wales, Lee Waters is no stranger to controversy. He reckons we still haven’t cracked it when it comes to messaging.

Behavioural scientists often say take the emotion out of it, make things feel mundane. That was the aim with Welsh Government’s calm 20mph slogan: ‘A little bit slower, a whole lot safer’. But, as most people involved would admit, it wasn’t hugely successful.

There was a big backlash based on an emotional reaction, and the active travel sector tried to combat it with ‘Look at the stats’. Maybe we need some emotion in there too.

3. We need to stop repeating opposing arguments

Cycling UK’s Associate Director Duncan Dollimore set out a useful introduction to framing: a way to set the agenda by making careful choices about messaging.

He highlighted a mistake that many active travel organisations (including Cycling UK!) have often made – repeating opposing arguments to try and dispute them, which just reinforces them in people’s minds. For example: ‘These changes are not anti-car’. Once you start noticing it, you see it everywhere!

I’d recommend having a look at his introduction to framing slides for some more useful tips.

4. Think about the best messenger

A discussion about how to have better conversations led to this great tip: the best person to make the point isn’t necessarily you. Think about who the person you’re trying to influence will resonate with.

Can you invite politicians to an event or engagement activity rather than a meeting, and offer them an opportunity to talk to constituents? How about getting mums at the local school involved to lead and present your petition for a new cycle path, rather than the cycle campaign group?

And bike buses can melt even the stoniest of hearts… as Katie from Bike Worcester said: “Our campaigners are the kids cycling to school!” If you watch their brilliant Room to Ride video, I think you’ll agree.

5. Talk about what they want, not what you want

Cycling is massively important to you and me. It’s not important to most other people.

For politicians, it’s one small thing on a long list of things they’re trying to get done. But on that list might include things like:

  • Figuring out how to solve congestion problems at school drop-off time
  • Reviving the struggling high street
  • Reducing the pressure on local GP surgeries
  • Making sure a new housing development doesn’t create new traffic problems

How can you talk about your vision for the future in a way that tackles the problem they’re trying to solve?

Inspired? Find out more

There was so much thought-provoking information from the day that I found it hard to condense my pages of notes into just a few key points!

If you want to explore more of what was shared, have a look at the slides shared below.

Further resources

What you CAN do

If you want to help get more people on bikes and campaign for cycling in your local area, Cycling UK’s Cycle Advocacy Network will provide you with the tools, advice, support and contacts you need to get started.

Join CAN today